Lionel Tate: A Victim of the Felony Murder Rule and the Harsh Justice System

Lionel Tate has become synonymous with one of the most infamous cases in American criminal justice history. Convicted of first-degree murder for killing six-year-old Tiffany Eunick while wrestling, Tate received life in prison without parole – becoming the youngest person ever sentenced with such a harsh justice system penalty sentence. Many argue that Tate may have been victimized by both rules regarding felony murder charges and the harsh justice system, and should have his case reconsidered.

lionel tate

What is the felony murder rule?

The felony murder rule is a legal doctrine which holds that anyone engaging in any act which results in someone’s death by means of any felony is guilty of murder, whether intended or accidental. The intent behind this doctrine is to discourage people from engaging in dangerous felonies that might endanger human lives and thus deter people from participating in dangerous criminal activity that puts lives in peril.

Florida law makes the felony murder rule particularly broad and stringent; any intentional act that could reasonably be expected to cause physical injury to a child constitutes child abuse and is punishable as a felony, so anyone who abuses a child who dies from abuse is guilty of first-degree murder even if it was unintended or accidental.

lionel tate

How did the felony murder rule affect Tate’s case?

Tate’s case was judged according to the felony murder rule, so that prosecution did not need to prove he intended or realized his acts would likely kill Tiffany Eunick, or that an average child of his age would or should have known this would occur – all they needed to show was that Tate intentionally abused Tiffany and caused her death as a result of this action.

Tate’s defense attorneys attempted to show that his actions were simply imitative of those seen on television, and that he didn’t fully comprehend their potential danger. Furthermore, evidence was presented proving he suffered mental and emotional health issues, neglectful treatment by his mother and abuse. Their objective was to convince a jury of not guilty by reason of insanity or at least of lesser charges such as manslaughter.

However, the jury rejected Tate’s defense and found him guilty of first-degree murder. Given Florida law, life without parole was mandatory for this crime; therefore the judge expressed both regret and frustration at having no alternative but to sentence Tate accordingly. “Lionel Tate did not behave like any child but displayed acts that were cruel, callous and cold-hearted in nature”, according to Judge Sargent.

lionel tate

What happened after Lionel Tate conviction?

Tate’s conviction prompted widespread public outrage and legal debate. Many felt he was too young to bear full responsibility for his actions, while his sentence seemed excessively severe and harsh. Others maintained he was the victim of both the felony murder rule and its harsh justice system, and that he should be given another opportunity at rehabilitation.

Tate’s case garnered international and national media coverage, and was advocated for by various human rights groups and celebrities. After three years in prison, his conviction was overturned by an appeals court on grounds that his original attorney had not adequately pursued plea deals or explored other defense strategies; upon hearing this news he accepted an offer by the prosecution to plead guilty to second-degree murder; sentenced to one year of house arrest before moving onto 10 years probation.

Tate’s troubles did not end there. In 2005, he violated his probation by possessing a gun and robbing pizza deliveryman at gunpoint; for which he received 30 years for armed robbery and 10 for violating probation concurrently. Later on that same year he attempted suicide by cutting his throat with razor blade. Though he managed to survive the attempt he suffered severe injuries from it.

Tate is currently being held at Charlotte Correctional Institution in Florida and eligible for parole at 43 years of age in 2030.

lionel tate

Conclusion

Lionel Tate’s case is one of the most heartbreaking and contentious cases in American criminal justice history, raising important questions about the felony murder rule, juvenile justice, mental health issues, child abuse allegations, media violence incidents and human rights. Furthermore, this story highlights how one simple mistake can have life-altering repercussions for both parties involved.

Stay tuned to CHOPNEWS for the latest scoops and updates of Business News, Sports News, Technology News, World News and Entertainment News.